Third coast Vs TSS Tournaments
Third coast Vs TSS Tournaments
Now that I've fished both tournaments, I can honestly say I really appreciate the Third coast series more! The raffle and the food make a huge difference. Not to mention the price $75.00 for 3rd coast, $75+$15+$50 for TSS. (Plus Third coast donates the proceeds)
For me, the Third coast, Trout and redfish stringer is the ticket. Largest fish (oversized fish) is what makes it fun, CPR'ing all fish is better for the environment! Even though I think all redfish made it in TSS! But, If all you can catch is dinks on that given day, there are prizes for the smallest fish as well!
The only thing TSS had over third coast, is everyone enjoyed seeing the fish. I think putting the photos on the screen as you announce the winners could fix that!
The one thing I can't decided which is better is the start! Third coast is a shotgun start, which means you have to get up earlier and drive more, on the other hand it is much more fair, by that I mean if you want to fish at a place that is farther away you pay the price both ways in third coast, in TSS you are there waiting to launch and only have to drive once on your fishing time. TSS is better in this way for the environment (less fuel) Because the tournaments move around, the idea is to fish the local waters so I would have to lean to the third coast way!
These are just a newbies somewhat bias opinion as I am a new member of Jerry B's team. So thanks again Jerry and Deb for all you do!
For me, the Third coast, Trout and redfish stringer is the ticket. Largest fish (oversized fish) is what makes it fun, CPR'ing all fish is better for the environment! Even though I think all redfish made it in TSS! But, If all you can catch is dinks on that given day, there are prizes for the smallest fish as well!
The only thing TSS had over third coast, is everyone enjoyed seeing the fish. I think putting the photos on the screen as you announce the winners could fix that!
The one thing I can't decided which is better is the start! Third coast is a shotgun start, which means you have to get up earlier and drive more, on the other hand it is much more fair, by that I mean if you want to fish at a place that is farther away you pay the price both ways in third coast, in TSS you are there waiting to launch and only have to drive once on your fishing time. TSS is better in this way for the environment (less fuel) Because the tournaments move around, the idea is to fish the local waters so I would have to lean to the third coast way!
These are just a newbies somewhat bias opinion as I am a new member of Jerry B's team. So thanks again Jerry and Deb for all you do!
Last edited by 2manytoys on Tue Mar 31, 2009 12:48 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- 5moreminutes
- TKF 2000 club
- Posts: 2888
- Joined: Tue Sep 30, 2008 2:57 pm
- Location: Matagorda to Port Mansfield
they are definitely two different types of tournaments..Jerry and Deb run a great tournament...personally I think you get more bang for your buck with their series...and I enjoy the varied venues...I didn't fish the same water twice in any venue..and most I fished water I had never seen before...I like the shotgun start..without a polygraph it's the only way to ensure everyone starts at the same time..and I like the under and oversized fish you can count..also the trout help spread everyone out..so that kayakers aren't fishing on top of each other in the same marsh for redfish only..
the TKS is growing and hopefully there will have bigger and better things in it's future..the only disappointment I had with TKS was the venues...but I'm sure IKE, facilities, and the lack of respect for muddy waters played in those decisions (the last one jk)...I just hate that I will basically be fishing the exact same water for all the TKS...except MATAGORDA...that's where we're gonna tell the men from the boys and the women from the girls...that will be the big equalizer...
They're both great tournaments and we're lucky in Texas to have both series...Jerry, Deb....Jim....Scott....all great people who spend alot of their time organizing events so we can show up and compete and have fun...
the TKS is growing and hopefully there will have bigger and better things in it's future..the only disappointment I had with TKS was the venues...but I'm sure IKE, facilities, and the lack of respect for muddy waters played in those decisions (the last one jk)...I just hate that I will basically be fishing the exact same water for all the TKS...except MATAGORDA...that's where we're gonna tell the men from the boys and the women from the girls...that will be the big equalizer...
They're both great tournaments and we're lucky in Texas to have both series...Jerry, Deb....Jim....Scott....all great people who spend alot of their time organizing events so we can show up and compete and have fun...
I don't see how one could compare them. Both are totally different formats.
People will fish both, or one or the other for various reasons. Different strokes 4 different folks...type thing.
Me id rather fish, measure, and string. Rather than have to add aligning the fish, waiting for it stop flopping, make sure some object is in the frame... etc.
Besides nuthin beats a live weigh in in my book.
other people will play whats better for the fish, whats a fair start.. blah, blah, and so on... A person either likes something or not. There is not one format for all. Aint gonna happen.
Both are fine Tourneys. No need to compare them. Fish what you like.
People will fish both, or one or the other for various reasons. Different strokes 4 different folks...type thing.
Me id rather fish, measure, and string. Rather than have to add aligning the fish, waiting for it stop flopping, make sure some object is in the frame... etc.
Besides nuthin beats a live weigh in in my book.
other people will play whats better for the fish, whats a fair start.. blah, blah, and so on... A person either likes something or not. There is not one format for all. Aint gonna happen.
Both are fine Tourneys. No need to compare them. Fish what you like.
HogheavenHogheaven wrote:I don't see how one could compare them. Both are totally different formats.
People will fish both, or one or the other for various reasons. Different strokes 4 different folks...type thing.
Me id rather fish, measure, and string. Rather than have to add aligning the fish, waiting for it stop flopping, make sure some object is in the frame... etc.
Besides nuthin beats a live weigh in in my book.
other people will play whats better for the fish, whats a fair start.. blah, blah, and so on... A person either likes something or not. There is not one format for all. Aint gonna happen.
Both are fine Tourneys. No need to compare them. Fish what you like.
You are right they are both fine tournaments, but I disagree in why not compare them, while there are differences that won't change, because they are different styles.
But if one is doing something that the majority likes or dislikes. If that changes for the better they both can benefit and become better for all and continue to grow!
As far as my opinions that I shared, and those you shared. They are great for someone on the fence that doesn't yet have one, that may want to get involved.
- Coastal Country
- TKF 6000 Club
- Posts: 6110
- Joined: Wed Jan 24, 2007 5:21 pm
- Location: Seat of a Magic 14.5 ~ Santa Fe, TX
- ~BUCKSHOT~
- TKF 1000 Club
- Posts: 1582
- Joined: Sat Jun 16, 2007 11:31 am
- Location: sour lake, tx. (TEAM TKF)
- Contact:
SamSam wrote:
The point system in the Kayak Series make it easier to catch the leaders for A.O.Y. and T.O.Y.,
Based on the end of the sentence you like that, right?
My guess, that would depend on which end someone is currently sitting.
Are you saying you think it would help to adjust the point system?
- ~BUCKSHOT~
- TKF 1000 Club
- Posts: 1582
- Joined: Sat Jun 16, 2007 11:31 am
- Location: sour lake, tx. (TEAM TKF)
- Contact:
I think that the point system in the Thirdcoast is a little challenged!!2manytoys wrote:SamSam wrote:
The point system in the Kayak Series make it easier to catch the leaders for A.O.Y. and T.O.Y.,
Based on the end of the sentence you like that, right?
My guess, that would depend on which end someone is currently sitting.
Are you saying you think it would help to adjust the point system?
- Sam
- TKF 2000 club
- Posts: 2208
- Joined: Fri Sep 16, 2005 12:37 pm
- Location: Team Ocean Kayak - Galveston
- Contact:
Not necessarily, I think both point systems are ok (as long as you don't blank ) 3rd Coast puts the emphasis on winning, TSS puts the emphasis on being consistent.....back to apples and oranges again2manytoys wrote:SamSam wrote:
The point system in the Kayak Series make it easier to catch the leaders for A.O.Y. and T.O.Y.,
Based on the end of the sentence you like that, right?
My guess, that would depend on which end someone is currently sitting.
Are you saying you think it would help to adjust the point system?
- Ms addicted
- TKF 5000 Club
- Posts: 5414
- Joined: Sat Aug 14, 2004 10:49 pm
- Location: Moderatorville (aka Bayou Vista)
- Contact:
I agree Ty, I do like that venue although it raises the nerve level quite a bit I think. The 3C seems more laid back, relaxed. More like traditional kayaking events. The TKS is wound up a notch or two...super sponsors, cameras and that dang microphone, lol. (not that I am complaining )
I think it would be great though if the 3C can throw up images of the fish they are announcing in a slide show as they call off names. Possible?? I know its probably alot more work and might delay things more but it would be cool.
I think it would be great though if the 3C can throw up images of the fish they are announcing in a slide show as they call off names. Possible?? I know its probably alot more work and might delay things more but it would be cool.
- Ms addicted
- TKF 5000 Club
- Posts: 5414
- Joined: Sat Aug 14, 2004 10:49 pm
- Location: Moderatorville (aka Bayou Vista)
- Contact:
They are the same and different. Same as its competing to catch fish from a kayak, you have to catch fish, and there is strategy.
Different in that the starts are not the same. Shotgun start vs. call in. The shotgun start is easily enforced and makes us figure on how far we go. TRS has a call in start and a limit on where to go.
TRS has one fish to weigh in live, Third Coast the emphasis is on catching two different fish.
Both venues feed off each other and both are family run.
The TRS piggybacks off of the boaters and with out the boat series there would be no kayak series, thats why the locations are what they are.
I have alot of fun at both meeting friends, talking stories, and fishing.
Different in that the starts are not the same. Shotgun start vs. call in. The shotgun start is easily enforced and makes us figure on how far we go. TRS has a call in start and a limit on where to go.
TRS has one fish to weigh in live, Third Coast the emphasis is on catching two different fish.
Both venues feed off each other and both are family run.
The TRS piggybacks off of the boaters and with out the boat series there would be no kayak series, thats why the locations are what they are.
I have alot of fun at both meeting friends, talking stories, and fishing.
- TKFStubb
- TKF 5000 Club
- Posts: 5179
- Joined: Tue Jun 03, 2003 4:55 pm
- Location: Beaumont, Tx. area (Sour Lake)
- Contact:
Which is best?
I like 'em BOTH!
- DevilDogTx
- Posts: 106
- Joined: Wed Aug 22, 2007 11:11 am
- Location: Corpus Christi Tx.
-
- Posts: 807
- Joined: Sat Feb 24, 2007 9:13 pm
- Location: Teamless in Texas
I have only fished the 3C series but will give TKS a shot when I get to fish again. I like the philosophy behind the non profit 3C and the family feel. But can see how the live weigh in can be exciting!
To me it will always be about fishing with old friends and making new ones. Placing and getting a check just makes the wife happy
I say fish them both and continue to promote the great sport of kayak fishing.
To me it will always be about fishing with old friends and making new ones. Placing and getting a check just makes the wife happy
I say fish them both and continue to promote the great sport of kayak fishing.
- LIFTING REDS
- Posts: 127
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2008 9:40 pm
- Location: SAN ANTONIO
- Coastal Country
- TKF 6000 Club
- Posts: 6110
- Joined: Wed Jan 24, 2007 5:21 pm
- Location: Seat of a Magic 14.5 ~ Santa Fe, TX
About the same number each last year(@ 60) this year we had around 60 people at 3C Riviera and TKS just had 95 in P.A.Choupique wrote:Curious does anybody have the size of each.... how many contestants at each event for the last year say?
We're hoping for a big turn out for Third Coast - Freeport on April 18th!!!
Last edited by Coastal Country on Wed Apr 01, 2009 10:58 am, edited 1 time in total.
- Gofish!
- TKF 1000 Club
- Posts: 1199
- Joined: Sun Oct 09, 2005 9:31 pm
- Location: NW Houston (Barker & Clay)
Re: Which is best?
I know which one you like more this week.TKFStubb wrote:I like 'em BOTH!